High-profile inheritance dispute highlights importance of leaving a Will

Wed 22nd Jan 2025
A close up shot of two people's hands signing a last will and testament

A high-profile inheritance dispute has captured headlines after a man passed away without a Will leaving behind a complex family dynamic. The controversy stemmed from his extra-marital affair which revealed two previously unknown biological children. All five children had to navigate the legal process without a Will to guide the division of assets. This process in known as an intestacy.

The order of priority on intestacy is set out in Section 46 of the Administration of Estates Act 1925 (AEA 1925), as amended.

Where there is no surviving spouse (as in this case), the children of the deceased receive the estate. This includes legitimate, illegitimate or legitimated children. Herein lay the issue.

Mel Grose, Partner and Head of the Inheritance and Will Disputes Team , explores this case and the importance of making a Will. 

The case

Michael Gymer passed away in 2020, following the death of his wife, Julie, earlier that year. Michael and Julie had three children, Gregory, Lee and Shelley. When Julie passed away, her estate passed to her husband, Michael.

Unbeknownst to Julie and the children, Michael had been involved in an extra-marital affair. This had resulted in him having two other biological children, Charlotte and Joseph.

As Michael had not made a Will, upon his death his estate (worth approximately £461,000 including Julie’s estate) was dealt with under the Rules of Intestacy pursuant to s46 AEA 1925 meaning that it was to be divided equally between all five of his biological children. This meant that each child would receive in the region of £92,000.

Michael’s three oldest children argued this was unfair, as Michael’s estate included the proceeds of their late mother Julie’s estate. They were certain she would not have wanted her estate to go to the children resulting from her husband’s affair. Joseph, Michael’s youngest son, argued that Julie had in fact been aware of the affair so the intestacy should stand. He believed she would not have minded him and Charlotte receiving some benefit from her estate too.

The claim

The claim that was brought was argued on a ‘needs’ basis, with the judge, Recorder Jonathan Cohen KC, ruling that Michael’s older two sons, Gregory and Lee had a greater financial need than the other three children. Recorder Cohen KC also found that it was unlikely, in the circumstances, that Julie would have been aware of her husband’s affair.

Recorder Cohen KC ruled, that given Gregory and Lee’s higher financial need, a third of Julie’s share of the Estate should be set aside for Gregory and Lee’s benefit. This amounted to £170,000, with Gregory and Lee receiving £85,000 each.

The remainder of the Estate was then split equally between all five children, who received approximately £58,000 each. This was a seemingly pragmatic and sensible solution to the arguments by all parties including Julie’s estate comprising a large amount of Michael’s estate.

The importance of making a Will

This case highlights the importance of not only making a Will but also providing sufficient accompanying instructions or letters. We would always recommend, that whilst testamentary wishes are often a topic that people do not wish to discuss, it is infinitely better for family members to be fully aware of one’s wishes – especially where circumstances aren’t clear cut.

Coodes’ Wills and Probate team has been recognised as a leading practice for this work in the South West. If you need advice on any aspect of succession planning, estate management or will preparation, call 0800 328 3282. Alternatively, you can fill in our online contact form here. We would always recommend having a professionally prepared will.

For contentious issues surrounding an estate, Coodes’ Inheritance and Will Disputes Team are happy to assist. Contact the team on 0800 328 3282 or by using our online contact form here, to arrange an initial appointment.

Wed 22nd Jan 2025

Melanie Grose

Head of Personal Disputes

Related Services & sectors

Get in touch

Call us on 0800 328 3282, or complete the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Name(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Search News & Events

Popular

Pattern

Changes to Paternity Leave in April 2024: What do you need to know?

As of 6th April 2024, paternity leave will be changing to reflect a shifting attitude…

Read more

Pattern

Suspecting a Power of Attorney of financial abuse: what can you do?

What steps should you take if you suspect someone is committing financial abuse as a…

Read more

chambers ranked in, uk, 2025, codes
winner! clinical negligence team of the year
The law society Children Law logo
The law society Clinical negligence logo
The law society Conveyancing logo
The law society criminal litigation logo
The law society family law advanced logo
The law society family law logo
The law society mental health advanced logo
A logo for accredited personal injury
cyber essentials logo
association of personal injury lawyers. apil. accredited practice

Portfolio Builder

Select the legal expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

    Download    Add to portfolio   
    Portfolio
    TitleTypeCVEmail

    Remove All

    Download


    Click here to share this shortlist.
    (It will expire after 30 days.)