We support businesses with commercially focused legal solutions that drive growth and protect and preserve your assets and reputations.
Whatever your business, we can help you prosper.
We provide legal support to address the major challenges in life and protect your family and finances.
From relationship breakdowns or personal injuries to property or criminal defence, we can help you achieve the best outcome for you and your family.
A recent High Court Judgment in Elliott v Bateson [2026] EWHC 2440 (Ch) provides an important reminder that a Will may be vulnerable to challenge even where there is no dispute about testamentary capacity and no finding of undue influence.
The case concerned the introduction of a Life Interest Trust into a Will and whether the Testator (the person making the Will) truly understood the effect of that arrangement. Whilst the facts arose in the context of a family dispute, the Judgment contains important lessons for anyone making a Will and for solicitors and Will writers involved in estate planning.
Perhaps most significantly, the case reinforces the importance of clear explanations, comprehensive attendance notes and ensuring that the Testator genuinely understands the effect of any proposed trust arrangement.
The case concerned the Estate of Mark Briant, who died in October 2022, the same year he made the Will in dispute.
Mr Briant’s original instructions were that his wife, Rosemary, should receive 50% of his Estate. However, during the Will-drafting process, a Life Interest Trust was introduced in place of an outright gift.
A Life Interest Trust is a common estate-planning tool. In simple terms, it allows one person to benefit from assets during their lifetime whilst preserving the underlying capital for somebody else after their death. Such trusts are frequently used to provide for a surviving spouse whilst ensuring that capital ultimately passes to children or other intended beneficiaries.
Following Mr Briant’s death, Rosemary challenged the trust provisions contained within the Will. She argued that her husband did not know and approve of those provisions and therefore that they should not take effect. She also brought a claim for reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 on the basis that, if the trust was valid, she would not receive reasonable provision from the Estate.
Importantly, this was not a case about whether Mr Briant had the mental capacity to make a Will. The Court accepted that he did. Instead, the dispute centred on the separate legal requirement that a Testator must know and approve the contents of their Will.
The Court found that the introduction of the Life Interest Trust fundamentally altered the nature of Mr Briant’s original instructions. The difference was not a technical drafting point. It changed the substance of the gift.
Under his original instructions, Rosemary would receive half of the Estate outright. Under the trust structure eventually included in the Will, she would receive the benefit of the trust during her lifetime, whilst the capital itself would ultimately pass elsewhere.
The Judge considered this distinction to be critically important.
In a passage that many private client practitioners and probate litigators will no doubt be referring to in future years, HHJ Michael Berkley stated:
“it was necessary for Mr Knight to carefully explain to Mark the implications of this fundamental change in the gift and to make sure that explanation was noted.”
The Judge was therefore not merely concerned about whether the explanation had been given. He was also concerned that there should have been a proper record demonstrating that it had been given.
Having reviewed the evidence, the Court concluded that this had not occurred. The Judge stated:
“From the evidence that I have seen and read he simply did not do so, and from what he did explain, Mark would have been misled. For the avoidance of doubt, I am not suggesting for a moment that Mr Knight was trying to hide those implications deliberately, but he seems either to have assumed a level of knowledge and experience that Mark did not have, or did not think through the implications of his suggested alteration to the gift..”
That finding is particularly striking because the Judge accepted that Mr Knight was “experienced, honest and truthful”. The criticism arose because the Court was not satisfied that the effect of the trust had been adequately explained and understood.
Many people assume that once a Will has been signed correctly it must be valid. The law requires more than that.
A Testator must have testamentary capacity, comply with the legal formalities for execution and also know and approve the contents of the Will.
Usually, knowledge and approval are readily established. However, where there has been a significant departure from a Testator’s original instructions, where complex provisions have been introduced or where the Will contains sophisticated trust arrangements, the Court may look much more carefully at whether the Testator truly understood what they were signing.
That is precisely what occurred in this case.
Having considered the evidence regarding the drafting process, the explanations provided and the surrounding documentation, the Judge concluded that Mr Briant had not understood the trust provisions which had been introduced into his Will.
The conclusion reached by the Court could not have been clearer:
“Mark did not know and approve the contents of the 2022 Will insofar as they created the life interest trust.”
The claim therefore succeeded on that basis.
The Judgment did not result in the entire Will being declared invalid.
Instead, the Court found that the provisions creating the Life Interest Trust could not stand because the necessary knowledge and approval had not been established. The Judge therefore ordered that the words creating the trust be struck out, leaving Rosemary with the outright gift of 50% of the Estate that Mr Briant had originally instructed. A separate allegation of undue influence failed and, as Rosemary had now received what she sought, the Judge made no additional award under the 1975 Act.
The outcome also illustrates that capacity, undue influence and knowledge and approval are separate legal concepts. A Testator may possess full testamentary capacity and yet still be found not to have understood and approved particular provisions within a Will.
The practical lessons emerging from this Judgment are significant.
Firstly, where a trust structure is introduced into a Will, it is essential that the practical consequences are explained in plain and understandable language. Legal terminology which may seem straightforward to an experienced practitioner may not be obvious to the person making the Will.
The distinction between receiving an asset outright and receiving only the benefit of a trust may appear obvious to a lawyer. This case demonstrates that it should never be assumed that the same distinction is obvious to a Testator.
Secondly, where there is a significant change from a person’s original instructions, that change should be expressly highlighted and discussed. The more substantial the change, the greater the need to ensure that the Testator understands its effect.
Thirdly, detailed attendance notes are crucial.
One of the most important aspects of the Judgment is the Judge’s observation that the explanation should have been carefully recorded. Attendance notes should not simply record the instructions received. They should also record the advice provided, the alternatives discussed, the advantages and disadvantages explained and, where appropriate, the Testator’s confirmation that they understood the proposed arrangements. In this case, the attendance note recorded that Rosemary “could have access” to the funds, wording which does not capture the real difference between a life interest and an outright gift.
Years later, when a dispute comes before the Court, it is often the contemporaneous attendance notes that provide the most persuasive evidence.
The Judgment also highlights the value of comprehensive follow-up correspondence. Where major changes have been made to a proposed Will, those changes should be clearly identified and explained in writing. Practitioners should not assume that a Testator will appreciate the legal significance of changes simply because they have received a draft document.
For anyone preparing a Will, the message is straightforward.
If a trust arrangement or anything disposing of their assets is suggested, it is important to understand exactly how it works and what it means in practice.
Questions should be asked if anything is unclear. Who will receive the assets? Who will control them? Who can access capital? What happens when the lifetime beneficiary dies? Does the arrangement truly reflect what is intended?
A Life Interest Trust can be an extremely effective estate-planning tool and, in many circumstances, may be exactly the right solution. However, as Elliott v Bateson demonstrates, a trust is only effective if the person making the Will genuinely understands and approves the arrangement being put in place.
The case serves as an important reminder that careful drafting is only part of the process. Equally important are clear advice, proper explanations and thorough attendance notes demonstrating that the Testator understood the effect of their decisions.
Disputes involving Wills and trusts often arise many years after a document has been prepared. Whether you are concerned about the validity of a Will, the circumstances in which it was prepared, or the interpretation of trust provisions, obtaining specialist advice at an early stage can be invaluable.
At Coodes, our specialist Inheritance and Trust Disputes Team advises individuals, families, professional advisers and Will writers on a wide range of contentious probate and trust disputes. We also advise solicitors and Will writers facing challenges to documents they have prepared and can assist in assessing potential claims, defending proceedings and navigating what are often highly complex and sensitive disputes.
If you have concerns about the validity of a Will or the way it was prepared, please get in touch.
About the Author: Hayley Gaffney is a Partner in the Inheritance and Trust Disputes team at Coodes Solicitors. She specialises in contested Wills, probate disputes, executor disputes, Inheritance Act claims, proprietary estoppel claims and all aspects of inheritance and trust litigation.
Get in touch: hayley.gaffney@coodes.co.uk 01872246200
Partner
Call us on 0800 328 3282, or complete the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.
As of 6th April 2024, paternity leave will be changing to reflect a shifting attitude…
What steps should you take if you suspect someone is committing financial abuse as a…